Inaros: Useless tank that does jack shit
A Tier.
Grendel: Fat Tank that kills everything and scales infinitely
B+
Bruh.
This. Also having Rhino above Khora, Vauban in C tier...etc.
I agree with Inaros' kit not doing a lot other than being status immune and beefy, but have you played Grendel in any mission past level 50? He doesn't scale enough at all and doesn't kill anything that matters fast enough. Past level 70 he'd kill more enemies with his belly than pulverize, and that's not saying a lot considering how slow he digests enemies, god forbid if you use him in any high level grineer missions. I'd say Grendel does more than Inaros, but all of that doesn't matter a whole lot if melee is faster and doesn't cost energy. At his current state he's a glorified toxin mod so you can have an extra mod slot for all your weapons, the rest of his kit doesn't do as much as you'd think.
I have played Grendel in missions past level 50. I have played Grendel in Steel Path missions. What I haven't done is play Grendel in Steel Path endurance missions past the 20min mark because I fall asleep at that point.
he'd kill more enemies with his belly than pulverize
Is literally the point. First off all Corpus enemies are instantly in an "Omae wa mou shindeiru" state as soon as they enter his belly because he does scaling Toxin damage when he spits them out, secondly high level Grineer will take up to 20secs to get destroyed but that's only to strip all their armour away.
So let's say I haven't fallen into a coma yet and I'm going up against lvl 400 Grineer. And there's 30 of them on the map. I will gobble them all up (and I do mean all of them) and in 20secs I can spit them out and they're all going to die to the resulting Toxin Proc which, again, scales with their health. Now IIRC it takes the average of their health and uses it in some way as a Toxin Proc so maybe the Heavies might survive. But you can then just gobble them up again.
doesn't cost energy
Rage Tank Grendel easy. Dude has a really strong heal, can give himself damage reduction in the form of Armor... Whatever Inaros can survive, Grendel can survive.
3 out of 4 of Grendel's abilities are very useful. It's Regurgitation (3) that seems to be pointless.
The point isn't so much that he CAN kill enemies, of course he can. I specifically mentioned his problem is that he can't kill faster than melee. Having to rely on rage or an energy orb generating ability and then having to do all of the set up, including the 20s digestion time you've mentioned is exactly his kit's problem. I didn't say the rest of his kit does nothing, I said it doesn't do as much as you'd think, because it's too slow.
Abilities can be faster and more efficient at killing than melee, just look at Khora, Mesa, Saryn, Protea, etc. If a warframe's damage ability/s isn't faster or at least as fast at killing as melee or does something extra, it's not that different from being pointless imo. I don't think that's too much to ask when Mesa is in A tier.
This way of thinking is unhealthy for the game. It leads to either continued unsustainable power creep or riots toward even the slightest challenge introduced later on.
I thought we were making a goddamn tier list and was listing frames under Brozime's criteria; besides, why is it inducing power creep to ask for a frame that's falling behind to catch up again? It's not like Grendel being, say, 15 seconds faster at killing would make Mesa and other damage frames irrelevant. Also, if anyone is to blame for Warframe's power creep, it's DE. We don't get to call the shots, they do. We weren't the ones who designed Wisp's kit, they did.
You're missing the point anyway, the point is Grendel is just not A tier in Brozime's criteria. You can argue that he's fun and you love him and that's what's important; hell, I like him, too. But that's not part of the tier list's criteria for fuck sake.
Why is it inducing power creep to ask for a frame that's falling behind to catch up again?
Because the WarFrames that you are holding as the standard (Khora, Mesa, Protea, etc) are actually the high extremes of overpowered WarFrames. To ask every other WarFrame to catch up to that is power creeping the crap out of the game.
This game is already ridiculously easy without using those overpowered WarFrames.
Oh, and Brozime's criteria, among other things in that video, are also unhealthy.
Oh, so the MANY A tier frames that can kill faster than melee, it's their fault for being too strong, got it. Fucking...if there's more than 3 warframes that can nuke faster than melee, you'd think that it's more of the game's issue than the frames' fault. Grendel being faster at killing isn't going to change shit, and it's not because every frame should be killing machines as Mesa and Saryn are, it's because Grendel is a fucking warframe with a scaling AoE damage ability, and that damage ability is bound to be compared to melee, because every goddamn frame can use melee for free. The purpose of pulverize and the shotgun barf from his 1, even regurgitate is to damage enemies, and the goal of damaging enemies is to kill them. It's fair to put him in the same competition with the nuke frames too because that's what he does. Hell, he doesn't even have to catch up to Mesa, of course he doesn't have to. He just has to be faster at killing than melee, it's not asking a lot when his abilities costs energy and maintaining his stomach to cast, something that melee does not. You're missing the point again by completely avoiding the fact that I talked about how he should be at least faster at killing then melee
Oh, and Brozime's criteria, among other things in that video, are also unhealthy.
make your own goddamn tier list that has the fun criterion in it then, it's not like he is the only one on this planet who's qualified to make tier lists. You can argue that his way of listing frames is unhealthy for the game, but he's just a youtuber. If you honestly think a guy on the internet can dictate how you and the entire community plays the game and how a company makes their game, you're just wrong. I don't know what to tell you, his tier list isn't necessarily made for you, make your own tier list if it's bothering you that much.
Grendel starts being AMAZING past level 100 especially on steel path spawn rates.
"Inaros: A"
I don't know what I expected tbh
"Health Number Big therefore Good"
-Brozime 2018-2021
I don't think he's wrong given context. Inaros is the best warframe for dumb survival with no work or effort. He's not anywhere near the most tanky warframe, and he can't use shield gating, and he only has 2 abilities (neither of which are very good). But Warframe's playerbase consistently plays him more than almost every other frame in existence.
If you take into account playrate Inaros ends up an A because apparently Warframe's playerbase highly values being able to get up and make a sandwich mid mission. Sure Inaros doesn't bring good CC, or damage, and his tankiness is lower than almost any frame with damage reduction (or proper shieldgate usage). But that doesn't matter if players value turning their brains off and being immortal, because Inaros is the best at brainless tanking.
Given that context I don't think Inaros at A is wrong. But I do think it's telling of Warframe's playerbase that the frame that only has the niche of being able to afk for minutes on end is one of the most played.
I think alot of newer players use inaros because he requires no resources to be effective. And new players have little resources. Also, he is kinda the perfect warframe for new people.
Pros: easy to aquire, barely needs mods, abilities are low impact so doesn't need energy, can revive himself (useful since new players seem to run solo alot), innately tanky, 20% health on finisher is great sustain.
I would also add that it's telling of Brozime that he thinks a WarFrame that only has the niche of being braindead AFK tanky is somehow 'good'. And that's the case with him about anything - a WarFrame is only 'good' if they can braindead-kill everyone en-masse (Mesa).
But as soon as you need to switch on your brain even slightly, that's bad (Railjack).
If you make a tierlist for the general population, and the general population overwhelmingly thinks braindead tanking is good, then by necessity the tierlist would need to mark the braindead tank as good. It leads me to unfortunately think that the more braindead a Warframe is the 'better' they are, because Warframe's playerbase is mostly casual players who want to do something as easily as possible with as little thought as possible.
Even with that basis I don't agree with a lot of his rankings though. His tierlist can be useful to see a different perspective, but it's important to take into account there's things Brozime does not know or ignores that can make rankings wildly inaccurate (like Polarize's existence and Counter Pulse, or Baruuk's low duration build maxing his meter within a couple casts).
Yeah that makes sense, fair enough.
To be fair, his ability to full AFK disappears in like, Steel Path survival. Hildryn with Energy Siphon is my go-to AFKer for that.
If you just want a TL;DR (visualized version by /u/Kappa64)
Ash: B+
Atlas: C
Banshee: C
Baruuk: A-
Chroma: A-
Ember: A-
Equinox: A-
Excalibur: B+
Frost: D
Gara: A+
Garuda: B
Gauss: A-
Grendel: B+
Harrow: C
Hildryn: B+
Hydroid: C
Inaros: A
Ivara: A
Khora: B+
Lavos: C
Limbo: C
Loki: C
Mag: B
Mesa: A+
Mirage: B
Nekros: A
Nezha: A+
Nidus: B+
Nova: A+
Nyx: D
Oberon: B
Octavia: A+
Protea: A+
Revenant: B
Rhino: A+
Saryn: A+
Titania: B+
Trinity: B
Valkyr: C
Vauban: C
Volt: C
Wisp: A+
Wukong: B
Xaku: A-
Zephyr: C
If you want a tier list that doesn't really give a shit about fun and only really cares about making the game mind-numbingly easy, then you got a pretty spot on tier list. Otherwise, please just try stuff out and figure out what you like the most. Some frames really don't deserve to be as low as they because of this criteria.
It's not even correct under that criteria. Banshee's Sonar trivializes any content where you need something killed and the enemy in question can be affected by it, which is almost everything outside of Ediolons. But Banshee is "C" tier? That's ridiculous. People think Banshee is trash when the handful of us out here been knowing you can damn near speed run shit like isolation vaults by just spamming Sonar a few times, while you keep seeing threads pop up asking "what's the best frame to run ISO vaults?". I don't even bother answering anymore because I just get downvoted, like I'm making some insincere or joke suggestion or something or I'm an idiot.
A large number of the frames on the list are rated too highly as well. You got people running Saryn and Mesa at Excavation because they think they are "Top Tier" when they can't even protect an excavator, but Frost and Nyx, both frames who can, are listed as D the absolute lowest score? And this isn't even about the scoring anymore, I literally see people bringing these frames to Excavation expecting to do well and straight up cannot handle the task, often causing multiple breaks. But thank god they got the most kills though, we couldn't have made it through with out that "helpful" A tier assistance.
Inaros, the frame people are finally starting to realize is borderline useless, though has been said for years, is still A tier to this guy. How?
Myself and others have been openly critical of Brozime for ages now, complete with detailed explanations, and they usual just downvoted and ignored, despite him basically giving out bad advice. He's in part a big reason why the meta is so stale despite all the ridiculous things you can do in this game.
This tier list, like every tier list that has ever existed for this game and every other game, is complete and utter trash.
..you figured it out, I guess?
I'm saying it this time around because I know the subreddit loves to perpetuate half-baked opinions from Brozime and I just hate seeing that.
This is my first (and last!) time ever watching one of Brozime's video. There were quite a few terrible takes in his list, but I lost it when he said Wukong's 4 didn't do enough damage.
Meanwhile, I'm over here melting level 140+ enemies.
Yeah, I'm totally with you there! I almost lost it when he said that myself, as an MR30 Wukong main. And Wukong's actually able to melt enemies in Steel Path, by the way! XD
I'm 100000% with you mate. People like BruhZeem can just say whatever dumb nonsense comes to their mind which then sets the discussion of this game. See Railjack.
I'm just trying to remind as many people as possible that this tier list is complete dogshit.
Tanky frames that do something? C tier.
Tanky frames that just tank? A tier.
Dude.
I won't lie. When I started in 2018 I watched his tier list videos to get an idea of what warframes to play.
Now that it's been 3 years I think I can say that these videos aren't that helpful. Warframes are tools. It's like making a tier list of the tools in your garage.
And some tools are better than others.
Vauban is like the smallest combination wrench in a garage full of large bolts.
I think the point is you wouldn't use a hammer to chop wood.
Tier lists can be interesting mental exercises of "how many uses does this tool have", but the correct answer to "what is the best frame" is to ask "what are you trying to do?"
but that's what's being discussed in the tier list - harrow was a B because he was nichely useful in content such as eidolon hunts and less useful in other content, due to his gameplay style being difficult to maintain, therefore he wasn't rated higher due to his usage being niche, but not lower due to his usage being relevant, but then both operations arrived that made arcanes significantly more accessible, which lowered his ranking, since it became less relevant - like a uniquely-shaped screwdriver which, while not fitting into common screws, had its applications being used on the few screws that it did, having applicable relevance, but then over time uniform shape for the screws was established that made the screwdriver have less use - if you do find one with an old screw, yes, the screwdriver is useful there, but the requiredness of the screwdriver went down.
Dude, use full stops (periods if you're American). That is one sentence.
hyphons were meant to convey sentence enders & i speak in run-on sentences like that due to brain stuff so i like to make my text equivalent
idk man, his tier list seem to be getting more and more out of touch. I know one shouldn't expect him to know all the frames extensively, but putting so many frames with better cc and aoe nuke abilities, especially Vauban and Khora below frames like Ivara when half of this crowd shooter game's stages are mobile defense missions seems really inaccurate. Come on, Vauban can do 90% of steel path with relative ease, and Khora is good in every defensive mission including excavation and interception, doesn't that count for something?
Not to mention the fact that he disregarded Atlas being able to infuse armor stripping abilities, Banshee being able to use Arcane Ultimatum with Savage Silence and many other frames with a few flaws that could be patched with the helminth system while giving Protea an A+ as long as she can do crazy damage that you don't really need with Larva infused.
I know the man wants the game to be good and wants DE to take notice of the frames falling behind and fix them, I respect that, but we're trying to making a tier list here.
Khora makes any interception disgustingly easy, all the way into Steel Path. She's also capable of infinitely soloing any level of defense and survival, and probably disruption, though I haven't tried her on that. In excavation I've only ever been concerned with stray shots hitting the excavator through her cage, but that's probably because my range was too low. Khora's just a beast, even after the LoS nerf. Mandatory pick for any endurance loot runs I do these days.
Love he he says Harrow is bad even though pillage fixes his kit or that helminth gives banshee her needed survivablilty
What's wrong with his kit that requires Pillage?
Its just that pillage give Harris survivability and feeds in to his 2 imo it turns him into a rhino like frame
... As opposed to his 1?
pillage is much quicker and a huge aoe, you can cast it once and get maxed shields easily compared to his 1. I find it really speeds up his gameplay and actually allows him to do his stuff with frames like mesa being around, I shouldn't have said his fix his kit but improves him where he struggles and why brozime put him in c
You are not wrong, his tier lists are getting more and more ouf ot touch with the game (example could be when he talked about Oberon for Eidolons in 2021) and I'm saying that as someone who is actually following his content
He's made at least one factual mistake in the video; I think he just hasn't quite had the heart in the game compared to the previous years? Probably shows how difficult streaming is to sustain, the energy levels to keep that kind of interest over many years to make this standard of content.
I definitely disagree with his opinions on several Warframes but Brozime always articulates himself well and it was nice to hear a comprehensive review.
So Frost is in the D category, but Hydroid is somehow above him in the C category despite having no advantages over Frost whatsoever.
This sort of nonsense is why I dont watch Brozime.
I feel that. Yet I'm getting downvoted for saying it and explaining my reasoning. Frost is still pretty good, even up in steel path. He for sure can use some tweaks but he's not as bad as people think he is.
Exactly. Frost needs a rework to some of his abilities, no doubt about it. But putting Hydroid, the worst frame in the game at the moment who has absolutely zero uses outside of his farming niche, above him in the chart is just complete rubbish.
I really want to ask Brozime what makes Hydroid better than Frost.
If you ask I'm sure it'll just come down to his 4 augment. Despite the fact that no one even uses him to farm anymore with so many other less obnoxious farming abilities in the game. Frost brings quite a bit to any team but there are some obvious missions where you aren't going to bring him like Exterminate or Eidolons.
What I want to know is what he's considering "relevant" content since apparently there are others that can do this content that Frost can also do, but they're so much better to the point that he's D tier. If it's just ESO and Eidolons then there's about 30 frames that should be in D.
Farming frames are such a niche and Hydroid is a niche within that niche as well. If Brozime really does put Hydroid above Frost for that reason alone, that he very clearly is not being objective like he seems to think he is.
Agreed
Warframe revolves around loot. Hydroid increases loot (even if it's bad it's a loot ability). Hybrid and frost are equally bad except hydroid can also be used as a loot bot. Hence why hydroid gets a higher rank
Warframe revolves around loot yes, but specific farming is a niche. We play this game and earn loot passively through gameplay. Getting loot is basically a bonus that goes with the fun gameplay of this game.
But specific focused farming is an absolute chore even with farming frames and that is why it is a niche.
And Frost is nowhere near as bad as Hydroid. The fact you even think they are equal is just incredible. Without any augments, Frost can strip enemy armour completely in a nice radial AOE that ignores all physical objects in the world, freezes enemies in place which provides a nice bit of reliable CC and has a scaling globe shield that he can spam to get over 1 million HP.
Hydroid has absolutely none of this. He has four crap abilities that are all worse versions of things other frames have. The only reason Hydroid is even still in peoples inventory, is because of his loot augment and even now hes been phased put in that area with far more reliable and less clunky loot frames like Khora and Nekros.
Hydroid has no value whatsoever in this game. Frost towers over him in every single way.
When considering augments for frost you can use his 1 augment in order to boost your team's damage, then you can Helminth on Smite and its augment or Roar for an even higher damage increase for your team. Not a ton of frames have a team damage increase like this and are able to Helminth on a second one. Honestly that alone makes him more viable than many others frames for Eidolons which if we're judging Eidolons as relevant content then that should make him at least a B.
Warframe revolves around loot yes, but specific farming is a niche. We play this game and earn loot passively through gameplay. Getting loot is basically a bonus that goes with the fun gameplay of this game.
But specific focused farming is an absolute chore even with farming frames and that is why it is a niche.
Niche to you maybe and a chore yes. But that doesn't change the fact that targeted farming is still done very actively by many players. Anything that makes this go by faster is a big boon even if it's a relatively bad ability.
And Frost is nowhere near as bad as Hydroid. The fact you even think they are equal is just incredible. Without any augments, Frost can strip enemy armour completely in a nice radial AOE that ignores all physical objects in the world, freezes enemies in place which provides a nice bit of reliable CC and has a scaling globe shield that he can spam to get over 1 million HP.
Hydroid has absolutely none of this. He has four crap abilities that are all worse versions of things other frames have. The only reason Hydroid is even still in peoples inventory, is because of his loot augment and even now hes been phased put in that area with far more reliable and less clunky loot frames like Khora and Nekros.
Hydroid literally has an aug that strips armor. His 4 and 2 very easily let you lock down areas with cc. Frost's armor strip on his 4 is just inefficient You have to build a sizable amount of strength and either tank your duration or energy economy which on a frame with a small energy pool is not ideal (remember, not every player has zenurik and energize).
Who even uses snow globe outside of excavation? It is an active hindrance to you and your team in every mission that isn't excavation since it isn't even necessary in defense.
Hydroid has no value whatsoever in this game. Frost towers over him in every single way.
Hydroid is still a loot frame which makes him slightly better than frost. Both frames can fo very similar things but a little differently. Both frames are very outdated in the current landscape of wf. I personally prefer frost over hydroid but that doesn't change the fact that having even a single loot ability will help any frame maintain a modicum of relevance in a looter shooter.
But that doesn't change the fact that targeted farming is still done very actively by many players.
Everyone spends 90% of the time just playing the games normal missions and do not spend most of the time farming in one specific spot. People only go focused farming when they are low on a component.
As I have said and you have agreed; active farming in this game is a chore. And that is why people do not do it much and just farm passively while playing the game.
It is a niche in the fact a very very small amount of players actively enjoy focused farming 90% of the time. Everyone else just does it when they have to, not because they genuinely enjoy doing it and consider it one of the best ways to play the game.
Hydroid literally has an aug that strips armor.
Firstly, augments cannot excuse bad design. As I have already pointed out, Frost can strip armour without augments. That is an automatic point in his favour as he comes with built-in armour strip. Hydroid does not. I have always, always held the stance that if people are using an augment to defend a frame, then its obvious that the base frame itself has absolutely no value and needs to be looked at.
Also, even before the damage rework, Corrosive Barrage wasn't that great an ability because frames like Frost existed, who could cast a radial AOE that does not require line of sight to affect enemies, which means that he could effectively strip armour from an entire hall. Hydroid's armour stripping method, was far more slow and inefficient as he had to individually target the areas and the ridiculous projectiles from Barrage often missed enemies entirely and/or ragdoll them around, which made it far more annoying. It took Hydroid far longer to strip armour off of enemies.
But now after the damage rework, Corrosive Barrage is worthless as the nerf to corrosive effectively made it complete garbage.
His 4 and 2 very easily let you lock down areas with cc.
No they dont. You could make a very small case if the game was still based around really tightly packed corridors, but Warframe now consists of large open maps and tile-sets with a lot of verticality.
As I pointed out previously; Barrage projectiles sometimes outright ignore enemies altogether or get caught on objects in the world, which makes it hilarious unreliable. You also need to charge it up in order to get the most duration out of it, which is awful. Charge abilities are a negative in the current state of Warframe.
Swarm also is not much better as it is based entirely around the RNG mechanic. You are only ever 100% certain to hit enemies on the initial cast. Everything after that is up to the will of the Gods, as you then have to rely on the enemy AI and hope that they walk into the pitiful range of the very slow tentacles and hope the tentacles actually pick them up as sometimes, like Barrage, the tentacles don't even register enemies.
Also, the tentacles spawn in completely random, and often completely useless places, like behind crates, on the ceiling, under platforms/rocks/pipes etc etc. You have absolutely zero control over how effective Swarm is going to be as it is entirely random.
This is not good CC at all, as it is completely unreliable.
With Frost, you know his abilities will always be 100% effective and not based on RNG. When I cast Avalanche, I know for a fact that all enemies within a 30m radius from me, are going to be stripped of armour and frozen in place. That is a textbook example of reliable utility and CC. When I cast Swarm, I have absolutely no idea if the ability is going to be effective at CC'ing enemies beyond the initial cast due to the fact the tentacles spawn in completely random places.
Hydroid has absolutely none of the reassurance that frames with actually reliable abilities, like Frost, provide players.
Frost can lockdown rooms far more effectively than Hydroid can and its always been that way. Is Frost the best CC frame? No, not by a long shot. But is he better at it than Hydroid? Yes.
Who even uses snow globe outside of excavation?
People who play Frost, like me and its incredibly effective when I can just spam my globe over and over again in Steel Path survival and have shield with 1 million HP on it.
Hydroid is still a loot frame which makes him slightly better than frost.
In the farming area, sure. But in every single other category? 100% no. Its really disingenuous to claim that Hydroid is better than another frame, simply because he can do something that frame was never supposed to do in the first place. That's like saying Saryn is better than Loki because she can do more damage, even though Loki was never designed to do damage to begin with.
Both frames can fo very similar things but a little differently.
The only thing Hydroid and Frost have in common is their theme of water manipulation, nothing more. Frost is useful in the majority of Warframes gameplay, Hydroid is not.
Frost offers players an incredibly useful utility/CC ability with avalanche and a decent if slightly outdated shield that he can spam to get very high HP. Most importantly though; none of his abilities require charging, he doesn't require augments, he does not have his abilities effectiveness tied to RNG/environment and you do not need to sacrifice 95% of the gameplay in order to survive while playing him.
Hydroid offers you what? A rubbish unreliable projectile ability, a clunky useless movement ability, a comically bad tank ability which removes 95% of the gameplay and forces you to move at a snails pace and a horrible RNG-based CC ability that people only ever really use when doing dedicated farming, which is not often.
Both frames are very outdated in the current landscape of wf.
While Frost does need some attention from DE, two of his most important and recognisable abilities still manage hold up, as they are not reliant on the environment, not RNG based and are very useful in high level missions. Hydroid has none of this.
Like I said; if Hydroid never had his loot augment, he would have been forgotten much sooner.
Hydroid and Frost need attention sure, but in terms of who is the most in need, Hydroid wins by at least ten miles. In the pecking order, he is at the very bottom.
Brozime is being completely disingenuous by putting Frost below Hydroid in the ratings.
But that doesn't change the fact that targeted farming is still done very actively by many players.
Everyone spends 90% of the time just playing the games normal missions and do not spend most of the time farming in one specific spot. People only go focused farming when they are low on a component.
As I have said and you have agreed; active farming in this game is a chore. And that is why people do not do it much and just farm passively while playing the game.
It is a niche in the fact a very very small amount of players actively enjoy focused farming 90% of the time. Everyone else just does it when they have to, not because they genuinely enjoy doing it and consider it one of the best ways to play the game.
Neither of us have any data to back either claim up so this is a moot point. I believe active farming is done much more than you but that is just a feeling I get from looking at recruit chat.
Hydroid literally has an aug that strips armor.
Firstly, augments cannot excuse bad design. As I have already pointed out, Frost can strip armour without augments. That is an automatic point in his favour as he comes with built-in armour strip. Hydroid does not. I have always, always held the stance that if people are using an augment to defend a frame, then its obvious that the base frame itself has absolutely no value and needs to be looked at.
Also, even before the damage rework, Corrosive Barrage wasn't that great an ability because frames like Frost existed, who could cast a radial AOE that does not require line of sight to affect enemies, which means that he could effectively strip armour from an entire hall. Hydroid's armour stripping method, was far more slow and inefficient as he had to individually target the areas and the ridiculous projectiles from Barrage often missed enemies entirely and/or ragdoll them around, which made it far more annoying. It took Hydroid far longer to strip armour off of enemies.
But now after the damage rework, Corrosive Barrage is worthless as the nerf to corrosive effectively made it complete garbage.
Didn't say it was good, i said it was available. And i put it about on the level of frost' armor strip because they are both bad (if DE just removed the duration component of frost armor strip then it would be comparable to pillage and really good but needing to build strength, range, and duration just to make a part of 1 ability works is still bad). I also never said augments make up for bad design but if I'm looking to add extra functionality to my frame and the augment exists then why would i or any player not use it when augs are so cheap and easy to obtain?
His 4 and 2 very easily let you lock down areas with cc.
No they dont. You could make a very small case if the game was still based around really tightly packed corridors, but Warframe now consists of large open maps and tile-sets with a lot of verticality.
As I pointed out previously; Barrage projectiles sometimes outright ignore enemies altogether or get caught on objects in the world, which makes it hilarious unreliable. You also need to charge it up in order to get the most duration out of it, which is awful. Charge abilities are a negative in the current state of Warframe.
I forgot to even add in his 1 but i have never really had any consistency issues with keeping any kind of area locked down with hydroid outside of open world. And if you're in a cave system it works p much like any other map.
The charge time is not long at all and doesn't even have to be held if you want to snap cast it which is still effective.
Swarm also is not much better as it is based entirely around the RNG mechanic. You are only ever 100% certain to hit enemies on the initial cast. Everything after that is up to the will of the Gods, as you then have to rely on the enemy AI and hope that they walk into the pitiful range of the very slow tentacles and hope the tentacles actually pick them up as sometimes, like Barrage, the tentacles don't even register enemies.
Also, the tentacles spawn in completely random, and often completely useless places, like behind crates, on the ceiling, under platforms/rocks/pipes etc etc. You have absolutely zero control over how effective Swarm is going to be as it is entirely random.
This is not good CC at all, as it is completely unreliable.
Ive never had rng problems like that but that's simply one word against another so neither of our opinions matter.
With Frost, you know his abilities will always be 100% effective and not based on RNG. When I cast Avalanche, I know for a fact that all enemies within a 30m radius from me, are going to be stripped of armour and frozen in place. That is a textbook example of reliable utility and CC. When I cast Swarm, I have absolutely no idea if the ability is going to be effective at CC'ing enemies beyond the initial cast due to the fact the tentacles spawn in completely random places.
Hydroid has absolutely none of the reassurance that frames with actually reliable abilities, like Frost, provide players.
Frost can lockdown rooms far more effectively than Hydroid can and its always been that way. Is Frost the best CC frame? No, not by a long shot. But is he better at it than Hydroid? Yes.
Who even uses snow globe outside of excavation?
People who play Frost, like me and its incredibly effective when I can just spam my globe over and over again in Steel Path survival and have shield with 1 million HP on it.
Which actively make people like me leave missions because whenever the defense location is not static and i hate having to play around someone else's ability that actively limits my ability to use projectile weapons
Hydroid is still a loot frame which makes him slightly better than frost.
In the farming area, sure. But in every single other category? 100% no. Its really disingenuous to claim that Hydroid is better than another frame, simply because he can do something that frame was never supposed to do in the first place. That's like saying Saryn is better than Loki because she can do more damage, even though Loki was never designed to do damage to begin with.
That's the point i am making. That hydroids ability to enhance loot gain is that important in warframe. If frost had a lot ability he would instantly be better because farming is that important. However this is a difference of opinion and ideals because i believe that active farming is done much more frequently than you do so it's just opinions at this point.
Both frames can fo very similar things but a little differently.
The only thing Hydroid and Frost have in common is their theme of water manipulation, nothing more. Frost is useful in the majority of Warframes gameplay, Hydroid is not.
Frost offers players an incredibly useful utility/CC ability with avalanche and a decent if slightly outdated shield that he can spam to get very high HP. Most importantly though; none of his abilities require charging, he doesn't require augments, he does not have his abilities effectiveness tied to RNG/environment and you do not need to sacrifice 95% of the gameplay in order to survive while playing him.
Hydroid offers you what? A rubbish unreliable projectile ability, a clunky useless movement ability, a comically bad tank ability which removes 95% of the gameplay and forces you to move at a snails pace and a horrible RNG-based CC ability that people only ever really use when doing dedicated farming, which is not often.
Again I've never had problems keeping an area locked down with hydroid. Also an important note is hydroid does not require changing your build around significantly to make all the abilities function equally. Frost can do big aoe cc for a reasonable amount of time but you are sacrificing duration, strength, (which would be worse bubble and armor strip) or energy efficiency on a frame with a minuscule energy pool.
Both frames are very outdated in the current landscape of wf.
While Frost does need some attention from DE, two of his most important and recognisable abilities still manage hold up, as they are not reliant on the environment, not RNG based and are very useful in high level missions. Hydroid has none of this.
Like I said; if Hydroid never had his loot augment, he would have been forgotten much sooner.
Hydroid and Frost need attention sure, but in terms of who is the most in need, Hydroid wins by at least ten miles. In the pecking order, he is at the very bottom.
Brozime is being completely disingenuous by putting Frost below Hydroid in the ratings.
I'll just agree to disagree i think both frames are equally outdated in kit coherency and in-game functionality but that farming is a more important part of the game (again in my opinion cause i don'thave any hard data). Ideally DE just updates all the outdated, underperforming frames cause then everyone wins.
Cheers tenno
I can't with this guy. It's almost as if he doesn't understand certain frames.
He's completely sleeping on Grendel and Lavos, yet "Neck Ross" is at an A lol
Agree with a good bunch of these, disagree with some. Still going to use the WF I like to play the most tho (it's a game, if you are not having fun. why are you playing?)
I do appreciate that he attempts to give a good reason if he dinged a WF and how it can be improved, even if I didn't agree based off my own experiences. Some of the helmith combos he mentioned sound fun and I'm bout to go try out.
Inaros an A?! Hydroid as high as a C? Lol
Mag being a B is an actual joke since he doesn't understand her in the slightest. He thinks her polarize is a weaker pillage, but polarize is instant (no delay like pillage) max shield reset, and a damage multiplier before the augment comes into play. Shes legitimately the most broken frame in the game.
Broken: maybe not.
But one of the strongest WarFrames for sure.
I suppose yeah, but IIRC, there's no other frame that can (with helminth) have three different damage multipliers purely from abilities. There's probably others that can do other dumb things, but its funny how he doesn't understand how she even works.
3 different damage multipliers?
Magnetize, Armor Strip, and..... Armor Strip (until completion) again? Damn, I'm a Mag main and even I'm a bit confused....
Ohhh sorry I read that as 'without Helminth', ok yeah you're correct.
Polarize is also a damage multiplier if you read the ability info, not just an armor strip. The target of magnetize bubble (sadly just that one) will also get another damage multiplier added if they're hit with polarize, which then can feed into the multiplying damage sparks of breach surge. If you throw on the augment, its a straight up better pillage + shooting gallery.
Well that would explain why Fireworks Mag works as well as it does without even needing a weapon.
Oh also, breach surge makes them blind so, stealth multiplier adds even more to the oomph Mag has with it. Because then it sets off the chain reaction made by breach surge because when an enemy that's blinded by it will always send out the multiplied sparks, which are redirected by the bubble into the the rest of the enemies who will multiply that damage because they're blinded by it and... yeah.
Yeah, its kind of absurd.
And then you remember that Polarize can jam guns (with augment) for protection, strip or reduce armor, and instantly refresh shields.
Polarize + Magnetize is what starts that chain reaction.
Ok - good to know. I never really bothered to think about it in that level of detail. I just know if I chuck a bunch of dudes in a bubble and then throw a Breach Surge on them they'll blow themselves up.
And Fracturing Crush that shit.
Get your self a rivened exergis and you can forget about all that armor strip/helminth nonesense , mag can nuke even at steel path given the right terrain
The only reason Inaros makes it into A tier is because you can do long survival runs with him without using your brain due to his large amounts of HP in conjunction with his 1. He contributes nothing of value to a team, 3 out of 4 of his abilities are complete dogshit and he's by far the most boring frame to play. He's outclassed in DPS, Defence, CC, support and even as a tank there are much more fun options. He's got one thing going for him: big healths. That's it.
If I had to pick 2 things from this tier list is
A) he's ranking system is fundementaly flawed as it only consideres he calls "relevant" content which makes the tier list useful for the top 1% and at that point you don't make a tier list, they already know what to pick
B) with A taken into account one frame I'd have to hard disagree on is vauban as he is extremly useful in anything with a target to defend and tesla nervos deserves way more credit and photon blast can be pretty useful with a max range max power duration nuked build with the augment
What else would you make a tier list for? You don't need a tierlist for who can press E on a Capture target, or for who can do Hijack well for the twice a year Sortie that has Hijack. There is no point making a tierlist for irrelevant content. And there's no point considering a frame good for being decent at content no one runs.
I think a frame should be given points if they are specialized at doing something in particular such as vauban's lockdown ability and not just shoved to the side because "dps is literally the only thing that matters in content most people don't even run"
Damage is the only thing that matters in most current content being ran. Starchart levels die to a stiff breeze, Sortie 1 enemies die in 1-2 melee swings, and once you get to Steel path there isn't much draw for a dedicated defense frame since there's no reason to do endless missions (so damage stays the best option to finish the mission faster, especially since Acolytes enjoy dispelling abilities). The one meta thing area lockdown is really useful for is Arbitrations, but Vauban sucks for that because of the drones giving CC immunity.
Vauban should be higher than a C (due to his level scaling damage + Tesla Nervos), but he should not be higher than a C because of his CC. His CC isn't relevant for most content in Warframe, and the few times it is relevant his CC is worse and less functional than the other frames that bring CC.
The issue perhaps is people calling it a tier list when he calls it a review.
A tier list often has a specific metric in mind, a review can simply evaluate what a frame wants to accomplish and if they do accomplish it.
If a review is made it only a singular metric, like damage, of course CC frames will be bad at it, and that leads to very misleading information that simply isn't healthy for the game, because the issue often isn't the frame, and much like how you said, it's the lack of content for those frames.
But to be fair, when there is content for CC frames, Vauban and Limbo aren't even A+, they are out of the charts because they break the game unless there's mechanics that "makes them suck" like how you mention the Arbitration drones (which I disagree in scenarios outside of solo and in a party it's weeds out the bad players).
Still, the underlying issue isn't really the damage meta or the lack of CC frame content, it's the balance being broken to the point that missions were defence is necessary aren't worth doing as new content for the game (and honestly CC meta was extremely boring). People turned their eyes to moan about "everything is MD", but MD is basically a fever mode where the game spawns and drives enemies to a singular tile, it's not any worse than missions like Exterminate or Survival, but I guess anything that can't be beat under a minute is bad? (Because that's pretty much the only argument being thrown around that isn't too far-fetched and yet too silly to consider worth thinking about.)
I find it a shame people don't use CC as an offensive method, unless a "content creator" tells them that Protea works with Larva, while others try to discredit how silly things like Ensnare can be on Atlas because "only more damage is better, even if you spend far more time running around targeting single enemies or groups or 2~3".
All in all, a meta tier list is easy to make, if it does damage it's good, but a "review" using that metric and ignoring the purpose of the frame would be even worse.
In regards to relevant content, he ignores easy starchart shit because literally every frame can do that.
I feel like this is a very rational way to look at it. The "tier list" format is fundamentally flawed. Because you really can't say a Warframe is A tier without explanation. Invara is A but that doesn't make her good at Excavation. Context is important. And what someone considers to be "relevant content" VERY muchso matters on the person.
So I just watched the video, listened to the reasoning, and made my own decisions from it. Like I don't care if Baruuk is an A tier, I hate the way he plays, so I won't play him. And I love Frost...though I do agree he needs some help...my poor cold boy.
Also, as far as Vauban being a C, I feel it is accurate. He is a functional Warframe that either a) doesn't have a home or b) is outclassed by other frames. I feel that fits him really well, so he fits comfortably into C. His CC is top notch and he does good damage. Both of those let him clear content. But CC isn't really needed for most content, and his damage is just outclassed. But then again, it all depends on the content you do that determines if a frame is "functional" or "excellent".
Weird to put Nyx at D when Psychic Bolts alone makes her extremely good at Steel Path and Assimilate makes her literally invincible. And before you claim that her kit sucks, he gave Nekros an A solely based on Desecrate...
it's in-relevance of the availability of the option. could you play nyx and use her 2 as a defense strip? yeah. could you also subsume pillage on any other warframe (which also replaces the only other reason you'd want to play nyx in the defensiveness of her 4), or play other frames with equivalent or better versions of that tool, who also have other usable parts of their abilityset, such as xaku, ash, etc? also yeah. so why touch nyx?
additionally noted in that video (and other tierlists) is that many other frames are functionally invulnerable with upside, so why bother doing the whole thing of assimilate which is quite slow, when you could like... while this is controversial given the other takes here, play inaros and subsume shuriken onto him? psychic bolts isn't terrible, but it's not something that challenges the usefulness of anything else, and all other parts of nyx's kit are inconvenient or bad.
conversely, nekros' desecrate is ranked high because it's not something other frames do better or can be equivalently replaced. nothing overrides it, but things can assist with it, however it's reigning as the best option - you don't bring just atlas to a farming mission, you bring nekros, and then you can add other farming frames afterwards. armor strip is something that has equivalents that can replace it, so if you can have armor strip PLUS good things, then just take the thing that comes with extra stuff. (though i will agree that in this line of thinking, hydroid being at non-D is kinda wack)
This is stupid.
Inb4 people start going off about Inaros not being good just because he's boring
Oh he's good alright. He's good if you know absolutely nothing about any other frame and just want to breeze through certain missions with no thinking involved. He's good if you don't care about warframe abilities and only want a frame that can survive with a large health pool. He's good if you don't like contributing anything to a squad. He's good if you like to watch netflix while you're an hour into a survival.
Most people find that boring hence why he's one of the most requested frames for a rework. I personally judge a frame on more than their sheer amounts of health. If all abilities besides one are rubbish and they are boring to play then I don't care how much health they've got. I'd rather take literally any other tank over Inaros just because of how much of a snoozefest he is.
I judge a frame based on whether it is good or not. Being optimal is what I find fun, may not find playing optimal to be fun and prefer someone like Zephyr or Hydroid and that's totally fine.
Frost definitely doesn't deserve a D. While there are frames that can do things similar to his bubble he can cause an aoe 100% armor strip in a fairly large area, increase damage by a fair amount with his 1 augment, and his bubble is even still decent in SP. If you go with an Umbral build he's even fairly tanky. Honestly Frost is in a decent spot right now even if he isn't used much and his first two abilities and passive could use some work. If Hydroid is a C then Frost is easily a B with all the content he can still do (and do better than many others).
I like Brozime but he really seems to have a hate boner for frost. His kit certainly isn't as interesting but it isn't bad.
Frost is literally one of the worst frames right now. He preempts all this by saying that literally any frame can be used in the starchart and most content, but that he tiers these based on everything else. So in that regard, yeah Frost is absolutely at the bottom with Nyx.
And I explained my reasoning why I don't think he is, and you didn't address a single one of those points. What is this content that he's being rated and compared on?
I'm sorry, but if i need to spell out why he is one of the worst frames, then you dont know what is good or bad in warframe at all. He can still be used on starchart just fine and in Sorties I suppose, so chill chile.
Ah yes, an arrogant response that doesn't address anything but tries to undermine my credibility. Wonderful. I can in fact say whether things are good or not I should think. I've put in 2-3k (just including in mission hours) hours since I started in 2015 so I would say that I'm rather qualified to know what's good or not in this game.
[deleted]
You double commented.
Oh , thanks for the heads up Damm internet
Herewegoagain.jpg